banner

News

Apr 18, 2023

The Fat Tax Is Real, and Here Is the Proof

The body positive movement is on the rise, with people of all backgrounds, shapes, and sizes challenging conventional beauty standards. The plus-size community, of course, is also taking part. Its proud members are making their bodies seen and voices heard.

As plus-size men and women speak up about their experiences, many shed light about the challenges they face, too. One among them is the "fat tax."

Read more: Plus-sized model Tess Holliday says she wakes up every day to messages from people telling her she's unhealthy

Not to be confused with a tax imposed on unhealthy foods, many consider the "fat tax" to be "the differences in cost just for the plus-sized consumer," plus-size fashion and style blogger of The Curvy Fahionista Marie Denee told Business Insider. "You go to a site that carries plus [sizes 14 and above] and straight sizes [0 to 12] and it's the exact same top, but it's, like, three-to-five dollars more in plus."

According to full-figured fashion blogger Alysse Dalessandro of Ready to Stare, retailers are "charging more for those garments under the guise that, 'Okay, well, you're bigger so it takes more material.'" While that might be the case, she said, from a business standpoint, prices do not have to be decided with straight sizes as the reference point.

"If you priced based off an extra small," Dalessandro told Business Insider, "it's almost like you're prioritizing those customers, and to me that's just not fair." With almost 70 percent of American women wearing a size 14 or above, according to The Atlantic, those considered to be "plus" are far from the minority.

Read more: These models recreated a Calvin Klein denim ad to prove that men of all sizes are 'handsome and worthy'

Does the "fat tax" exist outside of just clothing?

"I feel like there is fat tax in everything," said Dalessandro. "We're charged more just to be in a space ... It's more societal than actual dollar."

Here are five real-world examples that prove the "fat tax" exists.

Companies like Target and Forever 21 have started extending their sizing to plus, but pricing can be different for those looking for sizes 1X and above. The same T-shirt at Old Navy, for instance, could cost $16.99 for straight sizes and $19.99 for plus sizes. Target's website also lists the same pair of women's wide leg lounge pajama pants by Colsie for straight and plus sizes, the straight-sized pants costing $19.99 and the plus-sized pants costing $21.99.

"Fitting into the flying sardine cans that we now call airplanes is difficult at the best of times," said Carrie A. Trey of the The Points Guy, "add to the equation the fact that the seats are designed for one specific body type that's not at all representative of everyone who makes up the 'flying public.'"

The post lists 12 different airlines and their "passenger of size" policies. Alaska Airlines requires passengers to pay for an extra seat if they "cannot comfortably fit within one seat with the armrests in the down position." United Airlines states that, "A customer flying in the economy cabin who is not able to safely and comfortably fit in a single seat is required to purchase an additional seat for each leg of their itinerary."

Finding budget-friendly furniture that accommodates a plus-sized frame can be a challenge.

The cheapest patio chairs sold on Home Depot and Target's websites support a weight of up to 250 lbs. With the average American man weighing nearly 200 lbs., according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, many in the plus-size community likely surpass the 250 lbs. mark, forcing them to buy more expensive furniture.

Mattresses, too, are not always made with the plus-size community in mind. People "don't even realize that the average mattress is designed for someone who is 250 pounds," said Dalessandro.

Among Business Insider's best ranked mattresses, though the Lucid memory foam mattress was ranked best affordable mattress, heavyweight users who tested it gave the latter some of its lowest scores, meaning for a good night's sleep, they likely would have to invest in a more expensive mattress.

"Biking while fat" can also get expensive. The cheapest bike on Bicycling magazine's list of the 14 best cheap bikes for every kind of ride costs $134.99. The cheapest bike on the magazine's list of best gear for big riders, specifically, is $910. New York City's bike sharing program Citi Bike has also come under fire as its bikes don't support a weight of more than 260 lbs.

In the '80s, Keith and Julane Davis started casket-making company Goliath Casket. They've since seen the demand for larger caskets grow.

''People are getting wider and they're getting thicker,'' Mrs. Davis told The New York Times in 2003.

Titan, which sells caskets at retailers like Walmart and Amazon, lists the starting price for its caskets on its own website at $999, with the oversize caskets starting at $1,499.

Read next

Read more: Read more:
SHARE